Outline – DNA and Biological Evidence
Outline – DNA and Biological Evidence
Research Question:
Should DNA And Other Biological Evidence Be Admissible in Court?
Introduction
Prevalence of innocent people put in prison
Number of people proven innocent by DNA and other biological evidences after imprisonment
Ethical question of admissibility of DNA evidence in courts
Thesis statement – DNA and other biological evidence should not be oversold in court and should only be considered in light of other available evidence.
Scope of the problem
Statistics of the people wrongfully incarcerated
Statistics of the number of people put in death row due to erroneous DNA testing and planted evidence
Statistics on rightful convictions using DNA and biological evidence
Success of DNA and biological evidence in solving civil and criminal cases
Paternity cases
Proof of death
Sexual Assaults
Ethical issues in DNA and biological evidence in criminal cases
Basic human error and human bias
Linking innocent people to crime
Surge in racial disparities
Violation of privacy rights
Study #1 Campbell et al., 2020
Can DNA be used to identify repeat offenders in sexual assaults?
Forensic DNA testing results examined from 7,287 samples in Michigan
35.7% identified as repeat perpetrators
Study #2 Rasool & Hussain, 2020
Does forensic science aid the process of decision making in courts?
How has DNA evidence been used to solve forensic cases such as paternity and relatedness
Are there errors in solving forensic cases using manual calculations?
Does ForeStatistics increase the accurateness and efficiency of DNA statistics?
Study #3 Schklar, 2019
Do DNA and other scientific evidence play an increasing role in criminal investigations and court proceedings?
Baye’s theorem in estimating the degree to which jurors should revise their belief that the defendant committed the crime given some incriminating trace evidence such as hair fibre, semen and blood
Should jurors consider trustworthiness of police officers conducting criminal investigations and collecting DNA evidence from the crime scene?
Conclusion
Summary statement of DNA and biological evidence and impact on society
Thesis statement – DNA and other biological evidence should not be oversold in court and should only be considered in light of other available evidence.
Future implications
Educate people on importance of DNA and biological evidence
Conduct more studies on reliability of DNA and biological evidence to allow admissibility in courts.